On August 8, President Trump issued a Presidential Memorandum to defer the payment of the employee share of social security tax from September 1 through December 31, 2021. But what, exactly, does this Payroll Tax Deferral mean, and should employers take advantage of it?

11 Things You Need to Know About the 2020 Payroll Tax Deferral

This payroll tax deferral was enacted by President Trump to provide relief to some employees through the end of the year. However, some points of the action are confusing or off-putting to employers and employees alike. Here’s what you need to know:

1. Employees Must Make Less than $4,000 Bi-Weekly to Qualify

The cutoff for qualifying for the payroll tax deferral is $4,000 bi-weekly, or equivalent amounts for other payroll schedules. There is no “phase out” for amounts leading up to $4,000 bi-weekly, so individuals making $3,999 every two weeks would qualify while individuals making $4,000 every two weeks would not.

2. It is the Employer’s Decision Whether to Offer the Deferral

Employers are not required to defer payroll tax for their employees during the deferral period. They can make the decision on a company-wide basis, and even on an employee-by-employee basis. However, keep in mind that only employees making less than $4,000 bi-weekly are eligible.

3. Commissions and Bonuses Apply

If you receive commissions or bonuses that inflate a paycheck to over $4,000 during the deferral pay period, you would not be eligible to receive the payroll deferral for that paycheck.

4. It’s Not All or Nothing

The payroll tax deferral is not based on an average bi-weekly income; it is based on the actual payroll being paid out to the individual every two weeks. While an employee may qualify one pay period for making less than $4k, they may not qualify the next pay period if they make more than $4k. It also means you don’t “opt in” for the entire period; you can start late or end early. This is one reason some employers are put off by the deferral since it can be difficult to track, especially with companies who have a large number of employees.

5. It is Employee-Side Social Security Tax that is Being Deferred

The tax being deferred is the employee-side Social Security tax, which is 6.2% of an individual’s income. Therefore, this is a benefit to the employee and not necessarily a fiduciary benefit to employers.

6. This is Only a Delay

The payroll tax deferral, at this time, is not a forgiveness; it is only a delay. These payroll taxes will be required to be paid back beginning January 2021. For most employers, this will mean withholding increased payroll taxes from January 1 through April 30. For employees whose annual wage remains the same between now and April 30, this will mean they have 2X as much Social Security tax withheld during this period (6.2% normal Social Security tax withholding plus a portion of deferred Social Security tax withholdings from 2020).

7. This Could Increase Net Pay for Some Employees

The reason this is being offered as a relief for employees is because it means that employees making less than $4,000 bi-weekly will likely see an increase in net pay. Social security tax is 6.2% of your wages, which means that this deferral could increase your net pay in that amount through December.

8. Paychecks Will Decrease for These Employees in January

Since the deferral is, at this time, a deferral, not a forgiveness, the amount withheld will have to be paid back beginning January 2021. The employer will have to recover the total deferred amount from the employee, which will generally mean that from January 1-April 30, 2021, paychecks will decrease 6.2% in addition to the regular payroll tax rate to cover these additional costs.

9. At This Time, Forgiveness is Not Guaranteed

The goal of this deferral is to have the payroll tax forgiven before the repayment period begins in January 2021. However, at this time, the issue is divided. Before signing the deferral tax memorandum, President Trump spent months pushing for a coronavirus relief legislation that would include a payroll tax holiday, but the proposition met resistance on both sides. Now, the president hopes to be able to turn the deferral into a payroll tax cut, but it would require congressional action. At this time, Democrats and Republicans have yet to reach an agreement on another coronavirus relief package.

10. Many Employers are Opting Out Due to Administrative Efforts

Changing payroll systems is always tricky. This is even more the case when the change only applies to some employees, only applies for a short period of time, and when the change will require a second update in the beginning of 2021 to recover the deferred amounts. Because of these administrative challenges, many employers are opting out of the deferral. For those employers who use payroll companies, many of these companies did not have these changes made and available at the beginning of the deferral period, so some employers who did opt in were not able to defer during the first payroll of the deferral period.

11. There is No Guidance in Place for Employers Who Lose Employees

Your employer will generally offer repayment of these withheld taxes in even amounts from January 1 through April 30, 2021, but if an employee changes jobs, the employer would still be liable for the payroll tax deferred. There are not yet any guidelines for how employers would recover the deferred payroll tax from employees who left prior to or during the payback period, but it is assumed that the employer would be able to withhold the entire deferred amount in a single paycheck. For some employees, this would mean their final paycheck would be significantly reduced.

Should I Take Advantage of the Payroll Tax Deferral?

Some businesses question whether they want to participate in the payroll tax deferral. This is because it increases administrative work for the next 8 months (4 months of deferrals and 4 months of paybacks). It also means that employees will receive less in take-home pay beginning January 1, 2021. Some companies are banking on the hope that Congress will pass legislation to forgive the deferred taxes, but at this time, there is no guarantee.

About the Author

Jill Tavey Outsourced CFO Preferred CFO

Jill Tavey is an experienced outsourced CFO with over a decade of high-level financial expertise and experience. Her ability to negotiate, make and maintain key relationships, and shape strategic direction has helped propel multiple companies through significant growth.

Jill Tavey, CFO

You may also be interested in…

3 Reasons you Need a Financial Forecast

If Your Company Doesn't Have a Financial Forecast, You're Wasting Time and Money Every company has goals. Where do you want your organization to be 5 years from now? 10 years? Most even have a general idea of the benchmarks you need to hit to get there—"By increasing...

Determining the Payback Period of a Business Investment

Whether implementing a new software system, adding office space, acquiring another company, or any other substantial investment, companies want to know how long it will take to recoup the money they spend on major purchases. The way to determine this is by calculating...

10 Steps to Prepare for Raising Capital

Finding funding for your business is a process that takes a lot of time and effort, especially during the startup phase. Many entrepreneurs fail in their first attempts at fundraising because they are poorly prepared. Others get themselves into trouble by choosing the...

How Can a Fractional CFO Help You Save Money?

In these days of economic challenges and changes, many companies struggle with uncertainty about the future, seeking tools and resources to best position their businesses for financial success. Often it can be beneficial to bring in a financial advisor who has...

What is a Capitalization (Cap) Table and Why Does it Matter?

What is a Cap Table? Capitalization tables, commonly called “cap tables,” are highly useful spreadsheets maintained by companies that have multiple owners or investors. Cap tables are especially important for private companies at startup and in the early stages of the...

Benefits of Finance & Accounting Staff Augmentation

Many companies experience times when they find their accounting departments short on staff or short on expertise. Sometimes emergencies and financial needs arise that are beyond the capability of their financial personnel to address. This is particularly true in times...

Qualities of an Effective Profit & Loss Report

A Profit and Loss (P&L) Report, also called a Profit and Loss Statement, is a key financial document that details a company’s income and expenses over a specific period of time. This time period is typically a month, a quarter or a year. Depending on company needs...

What Is a Quality of Earnings Report?

When a business sale, acquisition, or major investment is contemplated, one important step in the due diligence process is the generation of a Quality of Earnings report, sometimes abbreviated as QOE. Even though a company may have strong financial statements, those...

Complete Guide to Accrual Accounting

There are two methods of accounting: cash and accrual. In cash accounting, transactions are recorded when payment occurs. In the accrual method, revenues and expenses are matched and recorded at the time the good is delivered or the service is performed, regardless of...

3 Things to Know Before Choosing a Supplier

Choosing the right supplier for your business can be complicated, especially if a large portion of your product comes from a single company. For many companies, supplies are secondary only to labor in their expenses. But choosing the right supplier has even more...

A CFO’s Role in Strategic Decisions

In every company, there are important decisions to be made on a daily basis. Some decisions are mundane and have only short-term consequences. Others are strategic and can affect the company’s performance and profits for years. Too often, these critical decisions are...